By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Join us
the Indian hawk logo theindianhawk logo dark
  • Home
  • India News
    • Defence
  • World News
  • Weapons
  • Opinions
  • Space
    • ISRO
  • Inspiration
  • Military Exercise
  • Videos
Reading: Gen Rawat’s ‘Clash of Civilisation’ Row Shows Military Should Be Seen but Not Heard in Press
Share
The Indian HawkThe Indian Hawk
Aa
  • Defence
  • India
  • World
  • Weapons
  • Opinions
  • Space
  • ISRO
  • Inspiration
  • Military Exercise
  • Uncategorized
Search
  • Home
  • India News
    • Defence
  • World News
  • Weapons
  • Opinions
  • Space
    • ISRO
  • Inspiration
  • Military Exercise
  • Videos
Follow US
© The Indian Hawk News Network. All Rights Reserved.
Home / News / Defence / Gen Rawat’s ‘Clash of Civilisation’ Row Shows Military Should Be Seen but Not Heard in Press
Defence

Gen Rawat’s ‘Clash of Civilisation’ Row Shows Military Should Be Seen but Not Heard in Press

News Team
Last updated: 2021/09/23 at 7:39 AM
News Team
Share
SHARE
follow on google newsjoin on whatsappjoin on telegram
Gen Rawat’s ‘Clash of Civilisation’ Row Shows Military Should Be Seen but Not Heard in Press

Page contents
CDS Statement And India’s Foreign RelationsWhy Restrict Media StatementsOther Indian Defence News Today:

by – Lt General Prakash Menon

On 15 September, the Chief of Defence Staff General Bipin Rawat posed a question before a gathering of Delhi’s strategic community. He asked them, rhetorically, whether China’s growing engagement with Iran, Turkey, and Afghanistan would lead to the rebooting of the ‘Clash of Civilisations’ theory with the Chinese and Islamic civilisations joining against the Western world? 

The query raised by the CDS was part of intellectual discourse and not, by any standards, a policy statement. But the media reported it as such and ended up seeding a controversy during a sensitive phase in China-India relations.

A day later, Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar chose to clarify the doubt before his Chinese counterpart Wang Yi during a meeting on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation in Dushanbe: “India had never subscribed to any clash of civilisations theory”. But the CDS, who is no stranger to controversies, again found himself at the receiving end. The episode raises questions about civil-military-media relations that need scrutiny.

CDS Statement And India’s Foreign Relations

The foreign minister’s clarification seems to indicate dissonance among the civil-military components of the government. The ground for dissonance was laid by the media that projected the CDS’ intellectual query as a policy statement. The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA), without due diligence, seemed to have blindly swallowed the media narrative. Worse, they may have seen it as an opportunity to score brownie points against China just before a high-level diplomatic interaction, at a time when relations are frayed and in need of repair.

The MEA contradicting the distorted context of the CDS’ remarks was certainly deliberate and may be viewed as deft diplomacy applied to further national interests. There is still the question of whether the CDS, who wears several heavy hats, should make public statements that impinge on India’s foreign relations?

National policy level statements could, under exceptional circumstances, emanate from any of the many heavy hats the CDS dons. But in our democracy, it will always be institutionally derived. Gen Rawat’s query was not a policy statement.

It emerged from an individual discourse probing the contours of global geopolitics. But to borrow a theory that stems from an American imagination and publicly clubs the Islamic civilisation as one entity with the Chinese is politically fraught in a world that the CDS himself described as being in “turmoil”.

 The CDS should avoid making public statements that could, in any manner, adversely impact India’s foreign relations. And the only way to minimise such occurrences is by keeping away from the media and public relations exercises.

Why Restrict Media Statements

The CDS and all military leaders must eschew the projection of personality through the media. They are better felt or seen and not heard; their appearance in the media should ideally be restricted to some special or ceremonial occasions. 

The media appearances of Gen Bipin Rawat, both as COAS and CDS, have left an avoidable trail of faux pas and opinions that have generated needless controversies. The media, especially for India’s military, will remain a double-edged sword. The digital world is unwieldy, unforgiving and easily amenable to distorting reality. As a policy, let the media spokesperson, who is now part of most military structures, do the talking and try their best to navigate the media minefield.

Some military leaders appear to be infected by the growing trend of image projection that is pertinent to the civilian domain, primarily in the realm of politics. The military does not have to go to great lengths to show off its achievements. Let the accomplishments do the talking, let not the pursuit of credit be the driver of media interaction.

Admittedly, in internal security engagements vis-a-vis Jammu and Kashmir and the northeast, the policy for media engagement must necessarily be shaped to counter the adversary’s efforts to paint the Indian armed forces as ruthless killers and an enemy of the populace acting as sycophants to New Delhi.

The recent use of fake tweets through a bogus Twitter handle of the Srinagar-based 15 Corps is revealing. A screenshot masquerading as the Twitter handle @chinarcorpsIA was circulating on WhatsApp on Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s birthday – “True Leadership is not about a Title or Designation, It’s all about Impact, Influence & Inspiration. #ChinarCorps extends heartiest birthday greetings to Hon’ble PM @narendramodi. 

We pray for your long, healthy & happy life full of zest and zeal. #HappybdayModiji.” Unfortunately, the tweet wasn’t disowned by the Chinar Corps or the ADGPI. It seemed to find unhindered publicity, attempting to portray a very distinguished and professional 15 Corps Commander as a sycophant. The military’s media organisations need repair.

An upright military leadership never claims personal credit. Instead, when the mission is accomplished, it makes the rank and file feel that they did it themselves. But some ambitious military leaders have jettisoned such niceties to pursue their personal goals of professional advancement. 

It is a trend that must be arrested and there is no better way to do it than through personal example — it must start with the CDS who is India’s apex military leader, ThePrint Reports.

Other Indian Defence News Today:

South Korea Missile Test: Major Test Conducted After North Korea

LAC Disengagement On Focus as S Jaishankar to Meet Chinese Counterpart in Dushanbe

Indian Air Force to Acquire 24 Second-Hand Mirage-2000 Fighters

Indian Army Launches Search Ops After Suspicious Movement in URI Along LOC

‘Surya-Kiran 15’: 14-Days Long Military Exercise Between India-Nepal Begins in Pithoragarh

India Has Made It Clear to China That Peace and Calm in Border Areas Are Vital for the Growth of the Two Nations’ Relationship

“Samudra Shakti”: Indian-Indonesian Navy Take Part in Maritime Exercise

Tata-Airbus to Clinch Rs 22,000 Crore Agreement to Build Military Planes

Need Time to Build Infra in NDA, Women Can Join by May Next Year Govt Tells SC

Air Marshal VR Chaudhari Set to Be Next Chief of Air Staff

TAGGED: Bipin Rawat, Indian Army
News Team 23/09/2021 23/09/2021
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Telegram Email Copy Link
By News Team
Follow:
Meet the dynamic and dedicated team behind "TheIndianHawk," your trusted source for breaking news, in-depth analysis, and thought-provoking features.
Previous Article Air Marshal VR Chaudhari Set to Be Next Chief of Air Staff
Next Article If South Korea Lifts ‘Hostility’ We Are Ready to Talk: Kim Yo Jong
Leave a comment

Latest News

  • Adani Wilmar Share Price loses by 3%, what you need to know
  • AILET 2024 Admit Card Out Now! Download link here
  • ED Raids Delhi Minister Raaj Kumar Anand’s residence ahead of CM Kejriwal’s Questioning
  • IND vs NZ CWC 2023 Updates: Rachin, Daryl Half Centuries Revive New Zealand’s innings
  • Jio Financial Services Stock in Spotlight As Q2 Profit Surge
  • Israel-Hamas War Enters 10th Big Day: Hostages, Truce Talks, and Escalation
  • Jyothi Yarraji’s Medal Upgrade Amid False Start Controversy at Hangzhou Asian Games
  • Karnataka News: JD(S) Members Pledge Loyalty Amidst Growing Discord
  • CBI Arrests Four in Connection with Abduction and Murder of Meitei Students in Manipur
  • Al-Jazeera, BBC Sparks Row, Posts Anti-Hindu Content, Twitter Reacts

You Might Also Like

Rafale Marine aircraft photo
News

India’s Bold Plan to Purchase 26 Rafale Marine Aircraft, Empowering Naval Capabilities

India's Defense Acquisition Council (DAC), chaired by Defense Minister Rajnath Singh, has granted initial approval for two crucial defense deals…

7 Min Read
Defence

Indian Armed Forces Eliminate 3 LeT Terrorists in Shopian

Shopian, Jammu & Kashmir: Indian armed forces Early on Tuesday morning, killed three local Lashkar-e-Toiba militants in a confrontation in the…

1 Min Read
Defence

Indigenous Loitering Munitions: Everything You Need to Know

Indigenous Loitering Munitions, also known as autonomous weapon systems, are cutting-edge military technologies that combine the capabilities of unmanned aerial…

8 Min Read

Gen. Manoj Pande COAS, Receives Honorary Title from Nepalese President Bidya Devi Bhandari

The Nepali Army receives non-lethal equipment from the Indian COAS.Gen. Manoj Pande, the head of the Indian Army's army staff,…

4 Min Read
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?