By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Join us
the Indian hawk logo theindianhawk logo dark
  • Home
  • India News
    • Defence
  • World News
  • Weapons
  • Opinions
  • Space
    • ISRO
  • Inspiration
  • Military Exercise
  • Videos
Reading: Army’s ‘Tour of Duty’ Proposal Is a Hare-Brained Idea; Won’t Be Good For India’s Frontline
Share
The Indian HawkThe Indian Hawk
Aa
  • Defence
  • India
  • World
  • Weapons
  • Opinions
  • Space
  • ISRO
  • Inspiration
  • Military Exercise
  • Uncategorized
Search
  • Home
  • India News
    • Defence
  • World News
  • Weapons
  • Opinions
  • Space
    • ISRO
  • Inspiration
  • Military Exercise
  • Videos
Follow US
© The Indian Hawk News Network. All Rights Reserved.
Home / News / Defence / Army’s ‘Tour of Duty’ Proposal Is a Hare-Brained Idea; Won’t Be Good For India’s Frontline
DefenceOpinions

Army’s ‘Tour of Duty’ Proposal Is a Hare-Brained Idea; Won’t Be Good For India’s Frontline

News Team
Last updated: 2020/12/25 at 1:20 PM
News Team
Share
SHARE
follow on google newsjoin on whatsappjoin on telegram

Army’s ‘Tour of Duty’ proposal is a harebrained idea. Won’t be good for India’s frontline


There are ideas, damned ideas and then there’s the Indian Army’s ‘Tour of Duty’ proposal. An ill-conceived scheme to allow young ‘Agniveers’ (military tourists, apparently) to follow the ‘Agnipath’ (serve in the combat forces) and experience the thrill of action where it’s at, in uniform for three years before moving on to other walks of life. Those taken in by the call to arms can presumably re-enlist and continue in Service as per the laid down terms of engagement for regular soldiers (who are only Veers).



The ostensible aim of such an exercise is manifold we are told; it will provide an opportunity to those youth fired by a desire to serve the nation but are unable to do so, because the current colour service norms for soldiers are too long; it will provide the Army (it may get extended to the Navy and Air Force as well) with the young personnel it needs on the borders, though for a very short time only, without any long-term financial burden, especially pension; and there would be a cadre of such well-disciplined Indian patriots ready to go back into civilian life and raise the bar for work and well being of society. And yes, it would even be an employment generator for India in trying times and reap the demographic dividend we haven’t really encashed thus far.


With such noble ideas, what could go wrong? Well, there’s enough in the proposal that needs to be examined and dissected to point out to the enthusiastic votaries of the scheme as to why this is such a hairbrained idea.


Glaring Problems 

To start with, under the regular terms of service and recruitment for officers and personnel, candidates undergo an entrance test, physical fitness and medical exam before trotting off to academies or training centres for nine-ten months to a year-and-a-half before being posted in the field Army.


 It is to be believed that there would be no entrance test for the agniveers. Now for a three-year tour of duty, even if such training is shortened — which is definitely not advisable if you are sending off the future agniveers to where bullets and shells may fly — effectively about 18-26 months would accrue in the kitty with field units, and some annual leave too would have to be given, or else the agniveer would be a very dull boy at the end of it all. 


Now imagine how such individuals, bubbling with national fervour, would be perceived in units where close cooperation and long-term bonding gets you safely through combat drills and dangerous situations. The reader may well imagine the muddle such induction of military tourists would induce in frontline fighting units.


A pertinent question we need to ask is, how are political leanings of such individuals going to be kept in check? 

They are only going to be in the armed forces for a short term and may be more inclined to show their like/dislike for a given political ideology, knowing full well that their Service conditions allow them greater leeway than a regular recruit for whom it is “naam-namak-nishan” and nothing else. This issue cannot just be brushed under the carpet because it has consequences for the much-needed apolitical character of the Army.


Finally, how well will these Agniveers perform and how will their work be judged against those of the regular cadre? Please think these through before enthusiastically creating a government notification for it, because the Army is not an adventure camp. It deals with serious life and death business, in which so many important issues are at stake.


Our sagacious leaders at the top are all well versed with the limited but important points highlighted here, and must not succumb to political pressure and accept even a pilot project to try out this scheme, let alone allow it to spread its wings to cover other Services as well.


There are other ways to reduce the burgeoning defence pension bill, but this scheme is definitely not it. If forced to push it through, the fighting efficiency and cohesion that our frontline units have displayed, even under the most trying circumstances, will be diluted immeasurably, and that would be a national travesty of our own doing.

The author is a retired Major General and was commissioned into the Armoured Corps in Dec 1983. Views are personal.

TAGGED: Agniveers, CDS, Indian Army, Tour of Duty
News Team 25/12/2020 25/12/2020
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Telegram Email Copy Link
By News Team
Follow:
Meet the dynamic and dedicated team behind "TheIndianHawk," your trusted source for breaking news, in-depth analysis, and thought-provoking features.
Previous Article How India Could Tweak China in the South China Sea
Next Article Border Tensions a Challenge to Defence Resources, but Govt Will Ensure Success, Rajnath Says Border Tensions a Challenge to Defence Resources, but Govt Will Ensure Success, Rajnath Says
Leave a comment

Latest News

  • Fun Ways to Exercise with Friends: Boosting Fitness in Active Social Settings
  • Adani Wilmar Share Price loses by 3%, what you need to know
  • AILET 2024 Admit Card Out Now! Download link here
  • ED Raids Delhi Minister Raaj Kumar Anand’s residence ahead of CM Kejriwal’s Questioning
  • IND vs NZ CWC 2023 Updates: Rachin, Daryl Half Centuries Revive New Zealand’s innings
  • Jio Financial Services Stock in Spotlight As Q2 Profit Surge
  • Israel-Hamas War Enters 10th Big Day: Hostages, Truce Talks, and Escalation
  • Jyothi Yarraji’s Medal Upgrade Amid False Start Controversy at Hangzhou Asian Games
  • Karnataka News: JD(S) Members Pledge Loyalty Amidst Growing Discord
  • CBI Arrests Four in Connection with Abduction and Murder of Meitei Students in Manipur

You Might Also Like

Rafale Marine aircraft photo
News

India’s Bold Plan to Purchase 26 Rafale Marine Aircraft, Empowering Naval Capabilities

India's Defense Acquisition Council (DAC), chaired by Defense Minister Rajnath Singh, has granted initial approval for two crucial defense deals…

7 Min Read
Defence

Indian Armed Forces Eliminate 3 LeT Terrorists in Shopian

Shopian, Jammu & Kashmir: Indian armed forces Early on Tuesday morning, killed three local Lashkar-e-Toiba militants in a confrontation in the…

1 Min Read
Defence

Indigenous Loitering Munitions: Everything You Need to Know

Indigenous Loitering Munitions, also known as autonomous weapon systems, are cutting-edge military technologies that combine the capabilities of unmanned aerial…

8 Min Read

Gen. Manoj Pande COAS, Receives Honorary Title from Nepalese President Bidya Devi Bhandari

The Nepali Army receives non-lethal equipment from the Indian COAS.Gen. Manoj Pande, the head of the Indian Army's army staff,…

4 Min Read
theindianhawk logo dark theindianhawk logo dark

Get Latest  Breaking India News, World News, Defence News, Space News and more on theindianhawk.com

Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram Whatsapp
  • Indian Army
  • Indian Air Force
  • Indian Navy
  • Indian Coast Guard
  • Indian Army
  • Indian Air Force
  • Indian Navy
  • Indian Coast Guard
Reading: Army’s ‘Tour of Duty’ Proposal Is a Hare-Brained Idea; Won’t Be Good For India’s Frontline
Share
  • Contact Us
  • Customize Interests
  • My Bookmarks
  • Opinions
  • Inspiration
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Code of Ethics (DNPA)
  • Write for us
  • Customize Interests
  • My Bookmarks
  • facebook stylish bio
© 2023 The Indian Hawk News Network | TIH Gadgets | Uttarakhand News | All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?