House Defence Panel Must Ask 4 Key Questions — From Lower Expenditure To Pension Bill

Share

Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence can bring much needed clarity on India's national security that Nirmala Sitharaman’s Budget didn’t answer

Indian Para SF Marching
Photograph Of Parachute Special Forces, During Republic Day March Past.

Lt General Prakash Menon And Pranay Kotasthane


When the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence meets this week to discuss the Budget allocations made by Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, we hope to get some clarity on the provisions made towards India’s national security. That’s because on defence, the Union Budget for FY2021-22 hides more than it reveals. Not only was ‘defence’ conspicuous by its absence in the finance minister’s Budget speech for the second consecutive year, the component-wise budgetary allocation also raises more questions than answers.

As the Committee examines the Demand for Grants of the defence ministry, we believe there are at least four important questions that the panel should ask.

Rising Threat, Declining Expenditure 

What explains the reduction in total defence expenditure even though the threat posed by China hasn’t gone away?


Despite the rhetoric, defence expenditure for FY2021-22 is estimated to be 1.35 per cent lower than the Revised Estimates for FY2020-21 in absolute terms. The Revised Estimates themselves increased by a marginal 2.3 per cent (~Rs 13,000 crore) over what was proposed in the last Budget. Total Ministry of Defence (MoD) expenditure as a proportion of GDP continues to languish at the 2.15 per cent mark. In a year that saw the economy contracting because of the pandemic and China adopting a confrontational posture on India’s borders, these numbers do not inspire much confidence. The Committee must ask the defence ministry if the Union executive is exploring all possible options to prioritise defence financing.

Money To Modernise 

Does the government have the financial headroom for modernisation of defence going ahead?


The Committee in 2019 had observed that the Budget allocation for modernisation, covering both committed liabilities and new schemes, did not meet even the committed liabilities. This has been the case since 2016-17, forcing the Committee to observe that inadequate allocation for committed liabilities could lead to India defaulting on contractual obligations. Long before the pandemic, even the financing of existing schemes was not guaranteed, leave alone new schemes for modernising the armed forces.

The government did course correct last year by increasing the capital outlay on defence (of which modernisation is also a part) by nearly Rs 20,000 crore during the pandemic, the Budget document revealed. Many post-Budget news reports subsequently claimed that this increase reflected emergency purchases of precision-guided munitions and drones to counter China. However, an increase of Rs 20,000 crore cannot be explained by these purchases alone. Major defence equipment isn’t available off the shelf and their payments are made over many years. So, where did the money go?

It’s more likely that the higher capital outlay was on account of payments for equipment purchased in the past. The budgetary allocations attest this claim to some extent. Of the Rs 20,000 crore increase, the Navy under the line items ‘naval fleet’ and ‘aircraft and aero engines’ accounts for nearly Rs 9,000 crore and the Air Force under ‘other equipment-air force’ accounts for another Rs 10,000 crore. Since the Budget documents don’t make any distinction between new schemes and committed liabilities, the Committee must ask the MoD to come clean on the modernisation plan.

Drop In Defence Pension Expenditure 

What explains the sudden drop in defence pension expenditure by nearly 13 per cent?

The Revised Estimates for FY2020-21 are lower than the Budget Estimates for the same year by nearly Rs 18,000 crore. This is surprising for two reasons. One, personnel expenses such as pensions are quite predictable. Two, after the introduction of One Rank One Pension, or OROP, pension outgo has been rising with a cumulative annual growth rate of over 17 per cent.

In such a situation, an absolute decline in pension expenditure is not possible without a sudden decrease in the number of retirees or a reduction in each retiree’s pension.

This sudden decline in pension outgo has sparked wild speculations. Some reports claim this reduction is due to a government proposal to increase the retirement age of officers, thereby decreasing the number of retirees. However, this move alone would still not explain a fall of nearly 13 per cent because the bulk of the pension expenditure is for personnel below officer ranks (PBORs). Moreover, this explanation still doesn’t account for a reduction in pension expenditure in the Revised Estimates of FY 2020-21.

Another claim being made is that a freeze in dearness allowance, in force since the pandemic, has caused a reduction in the pension outgo per personnel. This explanation is unsatisfactory because a decrease would have affected pay but not the pension amounts already fixed for the last year.

A third speculation is that previous years’ payments included arrears that have been compensated for already and hence the reduction in pension outgo. If that were the case, why did the Budget Estimates for FY 2020-21 include these arrears? This information is quite predictable and would have been available even before the FY 2020-21 Budget was made.

A final explanation for lower pension outgo is that the government is trying to book pension commitments over multiple years in light of the fiscal situation.

With speculations flying around, it is now up to the Committee to get the MoD to set the record straight on pensions. While reducing pension expenditure over the long term must remain an important goal, going back on existing statutory pension commitments would be counterproductive.

Revenue Concerns

What are the MoD’s plans to raise revenues on its own?


The government has given an in-principle nod to the 15th Finance Commission’s recommendation for creating a non-lapsable defence fund to finance modernisation. Three of the four sources for populating this corpus are under the domain of the MoD — disinvestment of Defence Public Sector Enterprises (DPSEs), monetisation of defence land, and transfer of defence land to state governments and public projects. The Committee must drive urgency in the MoD for raising revenues through these routes. It should ask the MoD to immediately identify DPSEs that need to be disinvested.

The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence can bring some much needed clarity to critical issues concerning India’s national security. What the Committee does will indicate whether legislative oversight over a powerful executive can work in the Indian setup.

COMMENTS

Name

16 Bihar Regiment,1,1971 War,4,26/11 Terror Attack,2,Act East Policy,1,Admiral Karambir Singh,1,advanced multirole combat aircraft (AMCA),1,Aero India,10,Afghanistan,4,Africa,1,Agniveers,1,Ahmedabad,1,Air Asia,1,Air Bubble,1,Air Bubble news,1,Air Chief Marshal,1,Air Chief Marshal Arup Raha,1,Air Force Station Yelahanka,1,AIR India,1,Air-Independent Propulsion,1,Airbus A330 multi-role tanker transport aircraft,1,Aircarft,1,Aircraft Carrier,1,Aircrafts,1,Airport Authority of India,1,Ajit Doval,1,Akash Air Defence Missile,2,Akash-NG Missile,1,Al-Qaeda,1,ALH Mk-III,1,Ambala,1,American Navy,1,American Predator drones,1,Amnesty International India,1,AMPHEX 21,1,Andaman & Nicobar Islands,1,Angara,1,Angara-A5 Space Rocket,1,Anti-radiation Missiles,1,Anti-tank Missiles,3,anti-torpedo defence system,1,Arabian Sea,1,Arakan Army,1,Argentina,2,Arjun Gun Barrel,1,Arjun Mark-1A,5,Armata Tank T-14,1,Armenia,6,Armenia-Azerbaijan War,5,Armored Vehicles,1,Arms Deal,1,Army,1,Army Commanders,1,Article 370,1,Article-II,1,Artificial intelligence,1,Artillery,1,Arunachal Pradesh,5,ASEAN,1,Assault Operations,1,Assault Rifles,2,Astra Mark 2 Missile,1,AstraZeneca,1,ATAGS Howitzer,2,Atal Tunnel,2,ATGMs,1,Atmanirbhar Bharat,5,Atmnirbhar Bharat,1,attari,1,Australia,6,AZAD Kashmir,1,Azerbaijan,6,B-1 Bomber,1,Balakot Attack,1,Balasore,1,Ballistic Missile Defence,1,Baluchistan,1,bangladesh,3,Banning of Chinese Apps,1,Beating Retreat,1,BECA Agreement,1,Beijing,2,Beirut,2,Belgian Malinois,1,BEML,1,Bengaluru,2,Bharat Dynamics Limited,1,Bharat Electronics Limited,1,Bharat Forge Limited,1,Bhawana Kanth,1,Bhutan,1,Bipin Rawat,5,Black Cats,1,Black Hawk Helicopters,1,Boeing,2,Boeing F-15EX Fighter Jet,1,Bolivia,1,BrahMos,6,Brazil,1,BRO,2,BSF,7,BSF Personnel,1,Budgam,2,C-295 Transport Aircraft,1,C-DAC,1,CAA,1,Cabinet Committee on Security,3,Cadet Amit Raj,1,CAPF,1,Captain Soiba Maningba Rangnamei,2,Captain Tom Moore,1,CDS,4,Ceasefire Violation,1,Chabahar_zahedan,1,Chamoli Glacial Outburst,1,Chandrayan-1,1,Chemical-Nuke-War,1,Chemical-Nuke-War Protective Gear,1,Chengdu J-20,1,Chennai,1,Chief of Defence Staff,4,Chile,1,China,115,Chinese AR-500 drone,1,Chinese J-18,1,Chinese VTOL Fighter Jet,1,Chushul,2,COAS,5,CoBRA Deputy Commandant,1,Cochin Shipyard,1,Col Quazi Zahir,1,Colonel Narendra Kumar Bull,2,Colonel Santosh Babu,1,Combat Air Teaming System (CATS),1,commission,1,Comptroller Auditor General (CAG),1,Congo,1,Corona Virus,1,Coronavirus,1,Coronavirus Vaccine,1,Covid-19,2,covid-19 pandemic,1,CRPF,12,Cyber Attack,3,Cyber Security,2,D.R.D.O.,25,DAC,1,Daily Knowledge Dose,3,Darwan Singh Negi,1,Dassault Rafale,2,DCNS,1,Defence,6,Defence Acquisition Council,1,Defence Budget 2020-2021,2,Defence Deal 2021,1,Defence Industry,6,Defence Insights,1,Defence Ministry,4,Defense budget 2021,1,DF-17 Ballistic Missile,1,DGQA,1,Dhruvastra,1,Difference Between LOC and LAC,1,Donald Trump,4,Dr APJ Abdul Kalam,1,Dr Vikram Sarabhai,1,Drones,2,Drones Attack,1,Ehsaas programme,1,Emmanuel Macron,1,Encounter,1,Enforcement Department,2,Euro Fighter Typhoon,1,European Union,1,Exercise SKYROS,1,F-35,1,F/A-18 Super Hornet,2,Farmer Protest,1,Farooq Abdullah,1,fast Petol Vessel,1,FATF,3,FBI,1,FBI Investigation,1,Festivals,2,Field Marshal Kariappa,1,Fighter Jets,5,Fiji,1,First Rocket Launch,1,fiscal year 2021-22,1,Fitness,4,FPfizer-BioNtech,1,France,7,Gabar Singh Negi,1,Galwan Valley,7,General Manoj Mukund Naravane,2,Germany,1,Ghazwa-e-Hind,1,Gilgit-Baltistan,1,Global,2,Golden Arrows Squadron,4,GRSE,1,GRSE yard,1,GSLV MK-II,1,Gulf,1,Guyana,1,H-20 Stealth Bomber,1,Hafiz Saeed,2,HAL,11,Hanwa Defence,1,Head-Mounted Display Systems,1,Heavy Lift Rocket,1,Helicopters,2,HELINA,2,Heron Drones,2,Hindustan Shipyard,1,HMS Queen Elizabeth,1,Hong Kong,1,Howitzer,1,IAF,5,ideaForge,1,IDEX,1,IED blast,2,Imran Khan,2,India,257,India-China disengagement,3,India-China Stand-Off,64,India-France,2,India-made Israeli Tavor X 95 rifles,1,India-Nepal air travel corridor,1,India-Pakistan,5,India-South Korea,1,India-US,3,Indian Air Force,52,Indian Air Force Day 2020,3,Indian Armed Forces,1,Indian Army,197,Indian Army Day 2021,1,Indian Coast Guard,5,Indian Defence News,340,Indian Defence Review,20,Indian Navy,33,Indian Ocean,3,Indigenisation,1,Indigenous Aircraft Carrier,1,Indigenous Rustom 2,1,Indo-Pacific,3,Indo-Pak war triumph,1,Indo-US,1,Indo-US 2+2,2,Information Security,1,INS Aditya,1,INS Himgiri,1,INS Kora,1,INS Mumbai,1,INS Sahyadri,1,INS Vikramaditya,1,INS Vikrant,1,INS Viraat,1,Insha Jan,1,Inspiration,7,International Defence Expo,1,Internet Shutdown,1,Interpol,1,Iran,7,ISI,2,ISIS,2,Israel,8,ISRO,9,ITBP,6,J-20 Stealth Fighter,1,J&K Reorganisation Bill,1,Jaisalmer,1,Jaish-e-Mohammed,5,Jamaat ud Dawa (JuD),2,Jammu & Kashmir,48,Jammu amp; Kashmir,3,Japan,6,JF-17,1,Joe Biden,4,K Sivan,1,KA-226T,1,KALI Secret Weapon,3,Kalyani M4,1,Karnataka,2,Kashmir,3,Kashmir Issue,1,Kavkaz 2020,1,Keerti Chakra,1,Kharga Corps,1,Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa,1,Kiren Rijuju,2,Konark Corps,1,Kozhikode air crash,1,Kulbhusan Jadhav,1,Kulbhushan Jadhav,1,Kulgam,3,Kumar Base,1,LAC,31,Ladakh,22,Ladakh Face-Off,49,Lamp;T Defence,1,Lashkar-e-Taiba,8,LCA Tejas,4,Lebanon,1,Leh,1,Leh-Manali,2,Lieutenant General Sarath Chand,1,Lieutenant General SS Mahal,1,Light Machine Gun,1,Linda Thomas-Greenfield,1,Line Of Actual Control,2,Lithium Triangle,1,LoC,10,Lockheed Martin,2,Lok Sabha,1,Louisiana,1,loyal wingman,1,LRSAM,1,Lt Gen. CP Mohanty,1,Made in India,2,Maharashtra,1,Make in India,2,Maldives,2,Manipur,2,Maritime,1,Maritime Exercise,1,Maritime Theatre Command,1,Mariya Didi,1,Mark-III ALH,1,Masood Azhar,3,MEA,14,Medium Calibre Guns,1,Mehbooba Mufti,1,MH-60 Romeos,1,MiG-19,1,MiG-21,1,Militants,1,Military Coup,1,Military Exercise,2,Military Modernization,1,Military Transport,1,Ministry of Defence,6,Mirage-2000,1,Mizoram,1,MK-III,1,MoD,3,Modern Haitat for troops,1,Modernization,1,Morocco,1,MoU,1,MPATGM,1,MQ-9B Drone,1,Mumbai,2,Mumbai Attacks,1,Myanmar,8,Narendra Modi,11,NASA,4,National Conference,1,National Security Adviser (NSA),1,National Security Guard (NSG),1,NATO,1,Naval Support Vessels,1,NavAlt Solar and Electric Boats,1,Navy,3,NCC,1,NDA,3,Nepal,3,NETRA,2,Neutron,1,Nguyen Xuan Phuc,2,NIA,6,Niger,1,Nigeria,1,Nike-Apache Rocket,1,Nirmal Jeet Singh Sekhon,1,Nirmala Sitharaman,2,North Korea,1,Northern Command,1,Norway,3,Nowshera,2,Nuclear Deal,1,Nuclear Installation,1,Nuclear Missile,1,OFB,1,Operation Meghdoot,1,Opinions,19,Optical Fibre,1,Ordnance,1,Organisation Of Islamic Cooperation,1,Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine,1,P-17A-Class Stealth Frigate,1,Pakistan,59,Pakistan army,1,Pakistan border,4,Pangong Lake,4,Pangong Tso,1,Paramount Group,1,Pavithra Wanniarachchi,1,Pentagon,1,Peru,1,PFI,1,Phantom Awacs,1,Philippines,2,Pinaka Rocket Launcher,2,PLA,17,PLAN,1,PLARF,1,PLASAF,1,PM Oli,1,PM Rally 2021,1,PoJK,2,POK,2,Poland,1,Poonch,6,Porta Cabins,1,pro-Donald Trump armed protests,1,pro-Navalny protests,1,PSLV,1,Pulwama,4,Pulwama terror attack,9,punjab,3,Purulia,1,PVC,1,Qatar,2,QRSAM,1,R K S Bhadauria,2,Rafael Advanced Defense Systems,1,Rafale,13,Raise 2020,1,Rajasthan,1,Rajnath Singh,24,Rajouri,5,Ram Nath Kovind,1,Republic Day Parade 2021,3,Riots in America,2,RKS Bhadauria,2,RLV-TD,1,RSS,1,RTEG,1,RUAV Drone,1,Rubaiya Sayeed,1,Rudram,3,Russia,13,Rustom-2,1,S Jaishankar,12,S-400 Missile System,2,SAAB,1,SAARC,1,Sabarmati Riverfront,1,Sachet,1,Sainik School,1,SANT,1,Saudi Arabia,1,Saudi Arabian Military Industries (SAMI),1,Scorpene Submarine,1,SeaKing choppers,1,seaplane,1,Sekhon Statue,1,Self-help,1,Senkaku Islands,1,Serum Institute of India (SII),1,SHADE,1,Shaheen (Eagle)-IX,1,Shahid Beheshti,1,Shaurya Missile,2,Shivangi Singh,2,Shoaib Akhtar,1,Shopian,3,Siachen Glacier,5,Smart Anti-Airfield Weapon (SAAW),1,Smart Shooter,1,SMASH 2000 Plus,1,sniffing dogs,1,Social activist & reformers,2,Social Media,1,Solar Powered Ferry,1,Solar-Powered Tents,1,Sonam Wangchuk,1,South Asia,1,South China Sea,1,South China Sea,6,South Korea,3,Southeast Asia,1,Southern Command,1,Southern Naval Command,1,Space,9,Space Agency Roscosmos,1,Space Situational Awareness,2,SPAD-GMS,1,Sri Lanka,2,Sri Lanka#039;s Muslim Council (SLMC),1,Srinagar-Leh,2,St Mary Magdalene,1,Stealth Destroyer,1,Student Death,1,Subhas Chandra Bose,1,Submarine,1,Sukhoi Su-30MKI,1,Sukhoi Su-30s,1,surveillance aircraft P-8I,1,Swarnim Vijay,1,Swarnim Vijay Varsh,1,SWITCH UAV,1,Switzerland,1,T-90 Bhishma MBT,2,TADA Court,1,Tahawwur Rana,1,Taiwan,6,Taliban,1,TATA Airbus Deal,1,TATA Group,1,Technology,14,Tejas,2,Tejas Mark II,2,TEJAS MK-1A,4,Terrorist Encounter,1,Terrorists,5,Terrorits,1,The Resistance Front (TRF),1,Theaterisation,1,theatrisation,1,Thumba,1,Thumba Equatorial Rocket Launch Station (TERLS),1,Tibet,2,Togo,1,Tour of Duty,1,TPCL,1,Transport Air Bubbles,1,TROPEX-21,1,Turkey,4,Turkey-Pakistan Nexus,1,Twitter,2,Type-928D Assault Boats,1,UAE,3,UAV,3,Ukraine,1,UN,2,UN Security Council,1,Unified Command Operations,1,United Nations,7,United Nations Peacekeeping,1,United States,16,US,31,US Navy,1,US Capitol,1,US elections,1,US-China,2,US-China economic and security review,1,US-India,1,UTTAM,1,Vagir,1,VCOAS,1,Vehicles,1,Verba Man-Portable Air Defense Sytem,1,Victoria Cross,2,Vietnam,2,Vijay Diwas,1,Vikas Kumar,1,Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre (VSSC),1,VK Singh,1,Vladimir Putin,2,VT-AXH Accident,1,War Heroes,2,Warrior Drone,2,Washington DC,1,weapon,1,Weapons,33,White House,1,World,219,World Health Organization,1,World War 1,1,Wuhan,1,Xi Jinping,2,Xi Jinping News,1,Xiaomi,1,Yasin Malik,1,Yudh Abhyas,2,
ltr
item
Defence News: Indian Defence News, IDRW, Indian Armed Forces, Indian Army, Indian Navy, Air Force: House Defence Panel Must Ask 4 Key Questions — From Lower Expenditure To Pension Bill
House Defence Panel Must Ask 4 Key Questions — From Lower Expenditure To Pension Bill
Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence can bring much needed clarity on India's national security that Nirmala Sitharaman’s Budget didn’t answer
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-BfI1ZupVnM0/YC4M6aC1ytI/AAAAAAAAQ2A/WK4hJdMS4ywKqwl96jExdA7gvMip0I68wCLcBGAsYHQ/w640-h350/Para%2BCommandos.webp
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-BfI1ZupVnM0/YC4M6aC1ytI/AAAAAAAAQ2A/WK4hJdMS4ywKqwl96jExdA7gvMip0I68wCLcBGAsYHQ/s72-w640-c-h350/Para%2BCommandos.webp
Defence News: Indian Defence News, IDRW, Indian Armed Forces, Indian Army, Indian Navy, Air Force
https://www.theindianhawk.com/2021/02/house-defence-panel-must-ask-4-key.html
https://www.theindianhawk.com/
https://www.theindianhawk.com/
https://www.theindianhawk.com/2021/02/house-defence-panel-must-ask-4-key.html
true
161742447869945643
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU TOPIC ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content