Dassualt Rafale and Sukhoi Su-30 MKI vs Chengdu J-20: A comparison

SHARE:

This analysis is about how the Rafale Fighter Jets and SU-30MKI can compete against Chinese J-20 or J-10 Fighter jets.

Rafale and Sukhoi Su-30 MKI vs Chengdu J-20
Dassault Rafale VS Chengdu J-20


The Indian Air Force will soon be equipped with state-of-art Rafale Fighter Jets which will be stationed at Hasimara Air Base while China already has 5th generation Chengdu J-20 jets. This analysis is about how the Rafale Fighter Jets and SU-30MKI can compete against Chinese J-20 or J-10 Fighter jets.


As reported earlier, the Indian Air Force officers in Hasimara have written to the defense ministry seeking clearance to relay the runway and build a hangar to accommodate both SU-30MKI and Dassault Rafale fighter jets.


The SU-30MKI is the most advanced fighter jets in the Indian armory who will now be complemented by the highly controversial, but competent – Rafale fighter jets. So, what will happen, when Chengdu J-20, the fifth-generation fighter jet comes face to face with Rafale jets?


Chengdu J-20: Specifications


Chengdu J-20: It is a single-seat, multirole stealth fighter for air-to-air, air-to-ground combat roles with supersonic cruise speed and integrated avionics which was test flown for the first time on January 11, 2011.

The jet, developed and manufactured by Chengdu Aircraft Industry Group (CAIG), is 20.3-20.5 metres long, has a height of 4.45 metres and its wingspan is 12.88-13.50 metres. The maximum take-off weight is 34,000-37,000 kg. The fighter’s range is about 1,200 kilometres which can be increased up to 2,700 kilometres with external fuel tanks.

While the J-20 is currently powered by the Russian AL-31 engines, China is working in a new and more powerful WS-15 (Emei) afterburning turbofan engine for the fighter for sustained supersonic speed. The aircraft can fly at a maximum speed of 2,100 kilometres per hour (about 1.8 mach) and its climbing rate is 304 metres per second.

There are two lateral bays with four hardpoints each for air-to-air missiles while the fuselage has a larger bay under it for carrying missiles and other weapons. It also has an internal cannon. It is equipped with an AESA radar along with a chin-mounted infrared/electro-optic search and track sensor.

The Chinese also claim that the J-20 has a passive electro-optical detection system which gives the pilot 360° coverage. The fighter, which has a glass cockpit with a bubble-shaped canopy, can access real-time data from Chinese military satellites, Divine Eagle anti-stealth Unmanned Aerial Vehicles and other airborne early warning and control (AEW&C) systems. The J-20 cockpit has two liquid crystal displays (LCD) and a head-up display (HUD). The J-20 can be operated through the traditional hands-on throttle and stick (HOTAS) system.


Sukhoi Su-30 MKI: Specifications


Sukhoi Su-30 MKI: The IAF’s twin-seater multirole fighter aircraft is the product of an Indo-Russia joint venture between Sukhoi Design Bureau and Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL). The Su-30 MKI is 21.9 metres long, 6.4 metres high and has a wingspan of 14.7 metres. The maximum take-off weight is 38,800 kg.

Powered by two Al-31FP turbojet engines, the Su-30 MKI can reach a maximum speed of 2120 kilometres per hour (Mach 1.9) and climb at a rate of 300 meters per second. The fighter has a fly-by-wire flight control system and a range of 3,000 kilometres without refuelling. Its combat range increases to 8,000 kilometres with in-flight refuelling system. The Su-30 MKI has a cruising height of 11 to 13 kilometres and a climb rate of 300 metres per second.

Its two pilots sit inside a tandem glass cockpit equipped with an integrated avionics suite incorporating Elbit Su 967 head-up display (HUD), seven active-matrix liquid crystal displays (AMLCD) and primary cockpit instrumentation. The aircraft also has multifunction displays (MFD) while t.he the rear cockpit has a monochromatic display screen for air-to-ground missile guidance

At present, the Su-30 MKIs have an N011M PESA radar which will soon be replaced with the more advance Zhuk AESA radar. The aircraft also has OLS-30 laser-optical locator system and Litening target designation pod to guide air-to-surface missile and laser-guided munitions.

The Su-30 MKI is one of the most heavily armed fighters in the world today. The IAF has modified 40 Su 30 MKIs to carry the supersonic BrahMos cruise missile. The fighter has a 30mm Gsh-30-1 cannon and 12 hardpoints capable of carrying missiles and bombs. The plane also has Tarang radar warning receiver and jammers for electronic warfare.

Dassault Rafale: Specifications


The Dassault Rafale is a French twin-engine, canard-delta wing, multirole fighter aircraft equipped with a wide range of weapons, the Rafale is intended to perform air supremacy, interdiction, aerial reconnaissance, ground support, in-depth strike, anti-ship strike and nuclear deterrence missions.

The Rafale is fitted with two Snecma M88 engines, each capable of providing up to 50 kN (11,250 lbf) of dry thrust and 75 kN (16,900 lbf) with afterburners. The M88 enables the Rafale to supercruise while carrying four missiles and one drop tank.

Although not really a stealth aircraft (as Chengdu J-20 claims), the Rafale was designed for a reduced radar cross-section (RCS) and infrared signature, which means it has some stealth features, which have neither been exaggerated neither been over-hyped.

The Rafale core avionics systems employ integrated modular avionics (IMA), called MDPU (modular data processing unit). The total value of the radar, electronic communications and self-protection equipment is about 30% of the cost of the entire aircraft, which is noteworthy.

The Rafale features an integrated defensive-aids system named SPECTRA, which protects the aircraft against airborne and ground threats. Various methods of detection, jamming, and decoying have been incorporated, and the system has been designed to be highly re-programmable for addressing new threats.


Dassault Rafale vs Chengdu J-20 vs SU30 MKI

China’s People’s Liberation Army Air Force (PLAAF) deployed its latest fighter Chengdu J-20 in February 2018 claiming it has stealth and is the most advanced fighter plane in all of Asia and comparable only with the American F-22.

However, according to various media reports, the Indian Air Force main fighter jet – the Sukhoi Su-30 MKI was able to detect the Chengdu J-20 flying over Tibet despite the latter using stealth technology. These claims can never be verified, but one thing is certain that Chengdu J-20 has question marks over its stealth technology and has no proven capabilities in a war.

The Chinese might have thoroughly evaluated the Indian SU-30 MKI jets, as they have jets based on similar Russian technology, but the French Rafales would be a complete surprise.

The Rafales, as stated earlier by EurAsian Times have invested around 30% of the cost of the entire aircraft on the radar and self-protection equipment which would make it extremely difficult to detect and shoot-down. That was one of the reasons why India preferred the French Rafales over the very advanced F-16s and Typhoons.

The French 4.5 Generation Fighter Jets, with proven war capabilities and tried and tested weaponry and radars has the potential to completely surprise the Chinese 5th generation fighter jets, which is still in the upgradation stage. It is highly unlikely that China will bring its J-20 face to face with the Rafale Fighter Jets anytime soon until they are self-assured of its capabilities.


COMMENTS

Name

16 Bihar Regiment,1,1971 War,4,26/11 Terror Attack,2,Act East Policy,1,Admiral Karambir Singh,1,advanced multirole combat aircraft (AMCA),1,Aero India,10,Afghanistan,5,Africa,1,Agniveers,1,Ahmedabad,1,Air Asia,1,Air Bubble,1,Air Bubble news,1,Air Chief Marshal,1,Air Chief Marshal Arup Raha,1,Air Force Station Yelahanka,1,AIR India,1,Air-Independent Propulsion,1,Airbus A330 multi-role tanker transport aircraft,1,Aircarft,1,Aircraft Carrier,1,Aircrafts,1,Airport Authority of India,1,Ajit Doval,1,Akash Air Defence Missile,2,Akash-NG Missile,1,Al-Qaeda,1,ALH Mk-III,1,Ambala,1,American Navy,1,American Predator drones,1,Amnesty International India,1,AMPHEX 21,1,Andaman & Nicobar Islands,1,Angara,1,Angara-A5 Space Rocket,1,Anti-radiation Missiles,1,Anti-tank Missiles,3,anti-torpedo defence system,1,Arabian Sea,1,Arakan Army,1,Argentina,2,Arjun Gun Barrel,1,Arjun Mark-1A,5,Armata Tank T-14,1,Armenia,6,Armenia-Azerbaijan War,5,Armored Vehicles,1,Arms Deal,1,Army,1,Army Commanders,1,Article 370,1,Article-II,1,Artificial intelligence,1,Artillery,1,Arunachal Pradesh,5,ASEAN,1,Assault Operations,1,Assault Rifles,2,Astra Mark 2 Missile,1,AstraZeneca,1,ATAGS Howitzer,2,Atal Tunnel,2,ATGMs,1,Atmanirbhar Bharat,5,Atmnirbhar Bharat,1,attari,1,Australia,6,AZAD Kashmir,1,Azerbaijan,6,B-1 Bomber,1,Balakot Attack,1,Balasore,1,Ballistic Missile Defence,1,Baluchistan,1,bangladesh,4,Banning of Chinese Apps,1,Beating Retreat,1,BECA Agreement,1,Beijing,2,Beirut,2,Belgian Malinois,1,BEML,1,Bengaluru,2,Bharat Dynamics Limited,1,Bharat Electronics Limited,1,Bharat Forge Limited,1,Bhawana Kanth,1,Bhutan,1,Bipin Rawat,5,Black Cats,1,Black Hawk Helicopters,1,Boeing,2,Boeing F-15EX Fighter Jet,1,Bolivia,1,BrahMos,6,Brampton,1,Brazil,1,BRO,2,BSF,7,BSF Personnel,1,Budgam,2,C-17s,1,C-295 Transport Aircraft,1,C-DAC,1,CAA,1,Cabinet Committee on Security,3,Cadet Amit Raj,1,Canada,1,CAPF,1,Captain Soiba Maningba Rangnamei,2,Captain Tom Moore,1,CDS,4,Ceasefire Violation,1,Chabahar_zahedan,1,Chamoli Glacial Outburst,1,Chandrayan-1,1,Chemical-Nuke-War,1,Chemical-Nuke-War Protective Gear,1,Chengdu J-20,1,Chennai,1,Chief of Defence Staff,4,Chile,1,China,115,Chinese AR-500 drone,1,Chinese J-18,1,Chinese VTOL Fighter Jet,1,Chushul,2,COAS,5,CoBRA Deputy Commandant,1,Cochin Shipyard,1,Col Quazi Zahir,1,Colonel Narendra Kumar Bull,2,Colonel Santosh Babu,1,Combat Air Teaming System (CATS),1,commission,1,Comptroller Auditor General (CAG),1,Congo,1,Corona Virus,1,Coronavirus,1,Coronavirus Vaccine,1,Covid-19,2,covid-19 pandemic,1,CRPF,12,Cyber Attack,3,Cyber Security,2,D.R.D.O.,26,DAC,1,Daily Knowledge Dose,3,Darwan Singh Negi,1,Dassault Rafale,2,DCNS,1,Defence,6,Defence Acquisition Council,1,Defence Budget 2020-2021,2,Defence Deal 2021,1,Defence Industry,6,Defence Insights,1,Defence Ministry,4,Defense budget 2021,1,Desert Flag,1,DF-17 Ballistic Missile,1,DGQA,1,Dhruvastra,1,Difference Between LOC and LAC,1,Donald Trump,4,Dr APJ Abdul Kalam,1,Dr Vikram Sarabhai,1,Drones,2,Drones Attack,1,Ehsaas programme,1,Emmanuel Macron,1,Encounter,1,Enforcement Department,2,Euro Fighter Typhoon,1,European Union,1,Exercise SKYROS,1,F-35,1,F/A-18 Super Hornet,2,Farmer Protest,1,Farooq Abdullah,1,fast Petol Vessel,1,FATF,3,FBI,1,FBI Investigation,1,Festivals,2,Field Marshal Kariappa,1,Fighter Jets,6,Fiji,1,First Rocket Launch,1,fiscal year 2021-22,1,Fitness,4,FPfizer-BioNtech,1,France,7,Gabar Singh Negi,1,Galwan Valley,7,General Manoj Mukund Naravane,2,Germany,1,Ghazwa-e-Hind,1,Gilgit-Baltistan,1,Global,2,Golden Arrows Squadron,4,GRSE,1,GRSE yard,1,GSLV MK-II,1,Gulf,1,Guyana,1,H-20 Stealth Bomber,1,Hafiz Saeed,2,HAL,11,Hanwa Defence,1,Head-Mounted Display Systems,1,Heavy Lift Rocket,1,Helicopters,2,HELINA,2,Heron Drones,2,Hindustan Shipyard,1,HMS Queen Elizabeth,1,Hong Kong,1,Howitzer,1,IAF,5,ideaForge,1,IDEX,1,IED blast,2,Imran Khan,2,India,262,India-China disengagement,3,India-China Stand-Off,64,India-France,2,India-made Israeli Tavor X 95 rifles,1,India-Nepal air travel corridor,1,India-Pakistan,5,India-South Korea,1,India-US,3,Indian Air Force,53,Indian Air Force Day 2020,3,Indian Armed Forces,1,Indian Army,198,Indian Army Day 2021,1,Indian Coast Guard,5,Indian Defence News,342,Indian Defence Review,21,Indian Navy,33,Indian Ocean,3,Indigenisation,2,Indigenous Aircraft Carrier,1,Indigenous Rustom 2,1,Indo-Pacific,3,Indo-Pak war triumph,1,Indo-US,1,Indo-US 2+2,2,Information Security,1,INS Aditya,1,INS Himgiri,1,INS Kora,1,INS Mumbai,1,INS Sahyadri,1,INS Vikramaditya,1,INS Vikrant,1,INS Viraat,1,Insha Jan,1,Inspiration,7,International Defence Expo,1,Internet Shutdown,1,Interpol,1,Iran,7,ISI,2,ISIS,2,Israel,8,ISRO,9,ITBP,6,J-20 Stealth Fighter,1,J&K Reorganisation Bill,1,Jaisalmer,1,Jaish-e-Mohammed,5,Jamaat ud Dawa (JuD),2,Jammu & Kashmir,50,Jammu amp; Kashmir,3,Japan,6,JF-17,1,Joe Biden,4,K Sivan,1,KA-226T,1,KALI Secret Weapon,3,Kalyani M4,1,Karnataka,2,Kashmir,3,Kashmir Issue,1,Kavkaz 2020,1,Keerti Chakra,1,Khalistani Group,1,Kharga Corps,1,Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa,1,Kiren Rijuju,2,Konark Corps,1,Kozhikode air crash,1,Kulbhusan Jadhav,1,Kulbhushan Jadhav,1,Kulgam,3,Kumar Base,1,LAC,31,Ladakh,22,Ladakh Face-Off,49,Lamp;T Defence,1,Lashkar-e-Taiba,8,LCA Tejas,4,Lebanon,1,Leh,1,Leh-Manali,2,Lieutenant General Sarath Chand,1,Lieutenant General SS Mahal,1,Light Machine Gun,1,Linda Thomas-Greenfield,1,Line Of Actual Control,2,Lithium Triangle,1,LoC,10,Lockheed Martin,2,Lok Sabha,1,Louisiana,1,loyal wingman,1,LRSAM,1,Lt Gen. CP Mohanty,1,Made in India,2,Maharashtra,1,Make in India,2,Maldives,2,Manipur,2,Maritime,1,Maritime Exercise,1,Maritime Theatre Command,1,Mariya Didi,1,Mark-III ALH,1,Masood Azhar,3,MEA,14,Medium Calibre Guns,1,Mehbooba Mufti,1,MH-60 Romeos,1,MiG-19,1,MiG-21,1,Militants,1,Military Coup,1,Military Exercise,2,Military Modernization,1,Military Transport,1,Ministry of Defence,6,Mirage-2000,1,Mizoram,1,MK-III,1,MoD,3,Modern Haitat for troops,1,Modernization,1,Morocco,1,MoU,1,MPATGM,1,MQ-9B Drone,1,Mumbai,2,Mumbai Attacks,1,Myanmar,8,Narendra Modi,12,NASA,4,National Conference,1,National Security Adviser (NSA),1,National Security Guard (NSG),1,NATO,1,Naval Support Vessels,1,NavAlt Solar and Electric Boats,1,Navy,3,NCC,1,NDA,3,Nepal,3,NETRA,2,Neutron,1,Nguyen Xuan Phuc,2,NIA,6,Niger,1,Nigeria,1,Nike-Apache Rocket,1,Nirmal Jeet Singh Sekhon,1,Nirmala Sitharaman,2,North Korea,1,Northern Command,1,Norway,3,Nowshera,2,Nuclear Deal,1,Nuclear Installation,1,Nuclear Missile,1,OFB,1,Operation Meghdoot,1,Opinions,20,Optical Fibre,1,Ordnance,1,Organisation Of Islamic Cooperation,1,Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine,1,P-17A-Class Stealth Frigate,1,Pakistan,60,Pakistan army,1,Pakistan border,4,Pangong Lake,4,Pangong Tso,1,Paramount Group,1,Pavithra Wanniarachchi,1,Pentagon,1,Peru,1,PFI,1,Phantom Awacs,1,Philippines,2,Pinaka Rocket Launcher,2,PLA,17,PLAN,1,PLARF,1,PLASAF,1,PM Oli,1,PM Rally 2021,1,PoJK,2,POK,2,Poland,1,Poonch,6,Porta Cabins,1,pro-Donald Trump armed protests,1,pro-Navalny protests,1,PSLV,1,Pulwama,4,Pulwama terror attack,9,punjab,3,Purulia,1,PVC,1,Qatar,2,QRSAM,1,R K S Bhadauria,2,Rafael Advanced Defense Systems,1,Rafale,13,Raise 2020,1,Rajasthan,1,Rajnath Singh,24,Rajouri,5,Ram Nath Kovind,1,Republic Day Parade 2021,3,Riots in America,2,RKS Bhadauria,2,RLV-TD,1,Rohinya Crisis,1,RSS,1,RTEG,1,RUAV Drone,1,Rubaiya Sayeed,1,Rudram,3,Russia,13,Rustom-2,1,S Jaishankar,12,S-400 Missile System,2,SAAB,1,SAARC,1,Sabarmati Riverfront,1,Sachet,1,Sainik School,1,SANT,1,Saudi Arabia,1,Saudi Arabian Military Industries (SAMI),1,Scorpene Submarine,1,SeaKing choppers,1,seaplane,1,Sekhon Statue,1,Self-help,1,Senkaku Islands,1,Serum Institute of India (SII),1,SHADE,1,Shaheen (Eagle)-IX,1,Shahid Beheshti,1,Shaurya Missile,2,Shivangi Singh,2,Shoaib Akhtar,1,Shopian,3,Siachen Glacier,5,Smart Anti-Airfield Weapon (SAAW),1,Smart Shooter,1,SMASH 2000 Plus,1,sniffing dogs,1,Social activist & reformers,2,Social Media,1,Solar Powered Ferry,1,Solar-Powered Tents,1,Sonam Wangchuk,1,South Asia,1,South China Sea,1,South China Sea,6,South Korea,3,Southeast Asia,1,Southern Command,1,Southern Naval Command,1,Space,9,Space Agency Roscosmos,1,Space Situational Awareness,2,SPAD-GMS,1,Sri Lanka,3,Sri Lanka#039;s Muslim Council (SLMC),1,Srinagar-Leh,2,St Mary Magdalene,1,Stealth Destroyer,1,Sticky Bombs,1,Student Death,1,Subhas Chandra Bose,1,Submarine,1,Sukhoi Su-30MKI,2,Sukhoi Su-30s,1,surveillance aircraft P-8I,1,Swarnim Vijay,1,Swarnim Vijay Varsh,1,SWITCH UAV,1,Switzerland,1,T-90 Bhishma MBT,2,TADA Court,1,Tahawwur Rana,1,Taiwan,6,Taliban,1,TATA Airbus Deal,1,TATA Group,1,Technology,14,Tejas,2,Tejas Mark II,2,TEJAS MK-1A,4,Terrorist Encounter,1,Terrorists,5,Terrorits,1,The Resistance Front (TRF),1,Theaterisation,1,theatrisation,1,Thumba,1,Thumba Equatorial Rocket Launch Station (TERLS),1,Tibet,2,Togo,1,Tour of Duty,1,TPCL,1,Transport Air Bubbles,1,TROPEX-21,1,Turkey,4,Turkey-Pakistan Nexus,1,Twitter,2,Type-928D Assault Boats,1,UAE,4,UAV,3,Ukraine,1,UN,2,UN Security Council,1,Unified Command Operations,1,United Nations,7,United Nations Peacekeeping,1,United States,16,Unmanned Ground Vehicle (UGV).,1,US,31,US Navy,1,US Capitol,1,US elections,1,US-China,2,US-China economic and security review,1,US-India,1,UTTAM,1,Vagir,1,VCOAS,1,Vehicles,1,Verba Man-Portable Air Defense Sytem,1,Victoria Cross,2,Vietnam,2,Vijay Diwas,1,Vikas Kumar,1,Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre (VSSC),1,VK Singh,1,Vladimir Putin,2,VT-AXH Accident,1,War Heroes,2,Warrior Drone,2,Washington DC,1,weapon,1,Weapons,33,White House,1,World,221,World Health Organization,1,World War 1,1,Wuhan,1,Xi Jinping,2,Xi Jinping News,1,Xiaomi,1,Yasin Malik,1,Yudh Abhyas,2,Zoji La Pass Tunnel,1,
ltr
item
Defence News: Indian Defence News, IDRW, Indian Armed Forces, Indian Army, Indian Navy, Air Force: Dassualt Rafale and Sukhoi Su-30 MKI vs Chengdu J-20: A comparison
Dassualt Rafale and Sukhoi Su-30 MKI vs Chengdu J-20: A comparison
This analysis is about how the Rafale Fighter Jets and SU-30MKI can compete against Chinese J-20 or J-10 Fighter jets.
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-eDbogWp7Jqs/YB-nLFNYMXI/AAAAAAAAQgA/6ITSMWrDEeEnARUI9te3n_MdDflbjnlcQCLcBGAsYHQ/s16000/Dassault%2BRafale%2BVs%2BChengdu%2BJ-20.webp
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-eDbogWp7Jqs/YB-nLFNYMXI/AAAAAAAAQgA/6ITSMWrDEeEnARUI9te3n_MdDflbjnlcQCLcBGAsYHQ/s72-c/Dassault%2BRafale%2BVs%2BChengdu%2BJ-20.webp
Defence News: Indian Defence News, IDRW, Indian Armed Forces, Indian Army, Indian Navy, Air Force
https://www.theindianhawk.com/2021/01/dassualt-rafale-sukhoi-su-30-mki-vs.html
https://www.theindianhawk.com/
https://www.theindianhawk.com/
https://www.theindianhawk.com/2021/01/dassualt-rafale-sukhoi-su-30-mki-vs.html
true
161742447869945643
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU TOPIC ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content